Happy Birthday from Nullsoft
It's my birthday today and the good folks at Nullsoft must have taken notice as they released Winamp5 yesterday just in time for the celebrations. This release is a huge step forwards (and backwards in a good way) from the previous versions of the program. I've always thought these guys were clever (they tell applicants they won't get the job if they use finger quotes) and the release of Winamp5 verifies this belief.
Winamp3 undeniably sucked. Whereas version two was light and efficient, three was heavy, crash-prone, and confusing. Well, the Nullsoft team shrewdly analyzed their folly and released version five (2+3) that takes the simplicity everyone appreciated in two and folded the few good elements in three into a new and much-improved product. It sounds so simple, but so few companies can criticize their own products and benefit from it.
The improvements I most notice are in the interface changes and they're worth applauding. Although I have reservations about skinning interfaces as opposed to using OS controls, if you're going to go down the path of skinning Winamp does it very well. Gone are the flashy moving parts and radical shapes of version three. Also gone are the tiny ambiguous controls of both previous releases. Nice.
The first thing you notice is that everything is a little bit larger than in version two. This allows for a couple of things. First off, skin designers can fit everything in while properly labeling everything. Both previous versions of the program suffered from ambiguous buttons and tiny clickable areas. In Winamp5, most of the controls are clearly labeled. Just look at the bottom of the playlist window. You no longer have to determine what the plus, minus, and SEL buttons mean. They actually tell you what you need to know. Second, it means everything is more legible at high resolutions. My laptop runs at 1400x1050 at only 14" and now I can actually read almost everything in the interface.
The second thing that jumps right out at you is the adoption of a simple windows-style top menu. Although strangely it doesn't seem to use the standard ALT-F command etc. to open the menus, it looks and acts almost exactly like a Windows menu. It's intuitive and helpful for editing preferences, loading files, and doing what you need to do.
Also of note, most actions have intuitive and strong reactions. Elements that should have hover effects have them. All buttons have fairly subtle on-click effects that increase the feeling that you've done something.
The colour options is another interesting new skinning feature. A single skin can have many different colour choices. The default skin can be coloured anything from 'Amethyst' to 'Varsity'. It's a nice feature when you like the features of the skin, but not its original colour scheme.
Of course, there are a handful of negative things too. Some of the pixel fonts are still miniscule, the whole thing seems a little more clunky than two but way more solid than three, the tray menus for your equalizer and video is strange (what's wrong with separate windows), it's still doesn't use default OS controls, and AOL still tries to get you to install stuff. However, bravo to Nullsoft for a big improvement and sound judgment¹. And, thanks for the present guys.
Comments
Steven Garrity - December 17, 2003 8:31 pm
Nice work Nullsoft, and happy birthday DTB (and N?B)!
Mandy - December 17, 2003 9:39 pm
Happy Birthday to you and Nick.
Adam Bramwell - December 18, 2003 8:40 am
I've been using a pre-release of WinAmp5 to navigate my way through a 50Gb Mp3 collection few months now, and it's handled the task brilliantly.
The only feature I could want for is a 'listen count' as Itunes has, to search out all those underplayed tracks I have hidden in subfolders somewhere..
Adam Bramwell - December 18, 2003 10:20 am
Oops, wished too soon; WinAmp5 now has both listen count *and* song rating systems, begorrah!
Now, back to hard-wiring my Mp3 server into the house sound system..
Daniel Burka - December 18, 2003 11:22 am
I just discovered that the ALT-F action does work in a way. As long as you hold down both keys at once it works. However, in a Windows application you can hit them in sequence and it works too. Maybe, they'll fix this in future releases of Winamp.
Lisa Sloniowski - December 18, 2003 3:08 pm
Happy (belated) birthday, Daniel.
ben - December 18, 2003 4:05 pm
has anyone figured out how to make "old skool" mode work in the modern skin?